Day 4
Job 4
Job 4
Eliphaz Speaks: Who Ever Perished Being Innocent?Introduction
With chapter 4 begins a long conversation between Job and his three friends. Eliphaz speaks first. He is polite and he is sincere, and he is wrong. His theology, that suffering is always the result of sin, sounds orthodox, but it is applied to a situation it does not fit. The chapter warns us about being too sure of ourselves when we explain other people's pain.
A Gentle Opening (Verses 1-6)
[1-2] Eliphaz asks permission to speak: "If someone ventures to talk with you, will you be grieved?" He adds, Who can keep from speaking?
[3-4] He reminds Job of his own past, that he has instructed many and strengthened weak hands. His words steadied those who stumbled.
[5-6] Then comes the turn: now trouble has come to Job and he is dismayed. "Isn’t your piety your confidence? Isn’t the integrity of your ways your hope?" It sounds like encouragement, but it hints that Job should be applying his own advice, and perhaps that something is wrong with his faith.
The Principle of Retribution (Verses 7-11)
[7-8] "Remember, now, who ever perished, being innocent? Or where were the upright cut off?" Eliphaz claims that those who plough iniquity and sow trouble reap the same.
[9-11] They perish by the breath of God. Like lions, even the strong are broken and scattered.
- The mistake: Eliphaz takes a general pattern in Proverbs (sin brings trouble) and treats it as an unbreakable law.
- The cruelty implied: If innocent people never perish, then Job, who is perishing, must not be innocent. He does not say it plainly yet, but he is saying it.
- The reader knows better: Chapters 1-2 told us Job was blameless. The friends' whole theory is tested against a man it cannot explain.
The Night Vision (Verses 12-21)
[12-16] Eliphaz describes a spirit passing before his face in the night, with a hush and then a voice. Fear and trembling came upon him and the hair on his body stood on end.
[17-21] The message is, "Shall mortal man be more just than God? Shall a man be more pure than his Maker?" God puts no trust in his servants and charges his angels with error, so how much more those who live in houses of clay. They are crushed like moths and perish forever without anyone noticing.
- A true point: No human being is pure before a holy God. The rest of Scripture agrees (Romans 3:23).
- A false use: The truth that all are sinners does not mean every sufferer is being punished for a specific sin. Eliphaz turns a general truth into a specific accusation.
- Mystic confidence: He rests his case on a private experience, a dream, and presents it as final authority. Scripture is more careful than this.
Key Takeaways
- True statements can be misapplied: Eliphaz says things that are partly right and uses them wrongly.
- Not all suffering is punishment: The book of Job exists to say so. See also John 9:1-3.
- Comfort needs humility: Explaining someone's suffering with certainty can wound more than it helps.
Reflection Questions
- What is good in Eliphaz's opening, and where does it go wrong?
- Have you ever been given a neat explanation for your suffering that did not help?
- How can we speak honestly about sin without blaming sufferers?
For Contemplation: Ask God to show you whether you ever explain other people's hardships too quickly. Pray for the grace to say, I don't know why, but I'm here.
Log in to track your progress