Jeremiah: broken cisterns
Jeremiah 2 is a heartbreaking love story gone wrong. God remembers the early days of the relationship: Israel followed him in the wilderness, in a land not sown, like a bride devoted to her husband. Now he asks, what fault did your fathers find in me, that they went far from me and went after worthless things and became worthless? Then he gives a verdict that has never been bettered as a diagnosis of the human heart: “For my people have committed two evils: they have forsaken me, the spring of living waters, and cut out cisterns for themselves: broken cisterns that can’t hold water.” (Jeremiah 2:13) The first evil is leaving the source. The second is the foolish attempt to dig our own reservoirs, which crack and leak. Think about what we dig. Success, approval, comfort, relationships, causes; even good things become broken cisterns when we ask them to be what only God can be. The water you carry back from them never quite satisfies. The invitation is implied: come back to the spring. Jesus said at the feast in John 7, “If anyone is thirsty, let him come to me and drink!” (John 7:37), and to the woman at the well he spoke of living water. Which cistern have you been drinking from, and where is the spring?
Jeremiah 2:1–13
Jeremiah 2
Two Evils: Broken CisternsIntroduction
Jeremiah 2 is a courtroom speech and a love letter at once. God begins with a tender memory of the early days, then asks what He did wrong that His people went so far from Him. The result is one of the most vivid images in the Bible: two evils, forsaking a spring and digging a leaking tank.
Remembering the Honeymoon (Verses 1-8)
[1-3] God recalls the devotion of Israel's youth: He remembers how faithfully they followed Him as a young bride into the wilderness, through land where nothing was sown. Israel was holy to the LORD, the firstfruits of His harvest.
[4-8] God asks what fault their fathers found in Him that they went far from Him and followed worthless idols and became worthless themselves. They did not ask, "‘Where is the LORD who brought us up out of?" The priests did not ask, the lawyers did not know Him, the rulers rebelled, and the prophets prophesied by Baal.
Two Evils (Verses 9-13)
[9-12] God challenges them to look across the sea to Cyprus and Kedar and see whether any nation has changed its gods, though they are not gods. Yet His people have changed their glory for what does not profit. The heavens are told to be astonished.
[13] "For my people have committed two evils: they have forsaken me, the spring of living waters, and cut out cisterns for themselves: broken cisterns that can’t hold water." The first evil is leaving God, and the second is trying to replace Him with something that cannot satisfy. A cistern was a storage pit for rainwater, and a cracked one is worse than useless.
Excuses and Consequences (Verses 14-37)
[20-28] Israel has broken the yoke and said, "I will not serve." On every high hill she has bowed like a prostitute. Though she washes with lye, the stain of her guilt remains. She says, "I am not defiled. I have not gone after the Baals." Yet she runs like a wild donkey in heat, and says, she has given up hope and will keep chasing the strangers she loves. They say to a tree, "You are my father," and to a stone, they credit it with giving them life. But in the time of trouble they say to God, "Arise, and save us!"
[29-37] God asks them why they plead with Him, when they have all rebelled. Their own sword has devoured their prophets. A bride does not forget her ornaments, but His people have forgotten Him for days without number. They will be put to shame by Egypt as they were by Assyria.
Key Takeaways
- God remembers early love: He recalls their devotion with affection.
- Idolatry is exchange: They swapped the glory of God for what profits nothing.
- Two evils: Leaving God and building substitutes.
- Substitutes cannot satisfy: A broken cistern holds no water.
- Denial deepens the problem: "I am not defiled" kept them from repentance.
Reflection Questions
- What "cisterns" are you tempted to dig, to find life apart from God?
- When did you last feel close to God, and what has changed?
- Why do we turn to God in a crisis after ignoring Him?
- How does Jesus' offer of living water in John 4 and 7 answer this chapter?
For Contemplation: God invites you to come back to the spring. Name one cistern you have been drinking from, and ask Jesus, the giver of living water, to satisfy you instead.
Reflection
What are you looking to for satisfaction that has repeatedly left you thirsty?
Log in to track your progress